Roland FP-10 vs Yamaha P-45: Which One Should I Choose?

Instruments Piano and Keyboard
1

Seeking Advice on Digital Pianos

I’m in the market for a beginner digital piano and I’m trying to decide between the Roland FP-10 and the Yamaha P-45. Both have some great features, but I’m really trying to dig into the specifics to help inform my decision.

Here’s what I’ve been considering:

  • Sound Quality: I’ve heard great things about the sound engines from both brands. How do they compare in real-world use? Any notable differences in tonal quality or expression?
  • Key Action: I’ve read that the FP-10 has a PHA-4 Standard action, while the P-45 features Graded Hammer Standard action. But, how does this feel for actual playing? Is one significantly more responsive than the other?
  • Connectivity Options: I’m interested in being able to connect to my computer or potentially use apps for learning. How do the connectivity options stack up for both pianos?
  • Overall Value: Considering everything from features, sound, build quality to price point, is one clearly the better option? Are there any hidden features or drawbacks that I should be aware of before making a purchase?

If anyone has experience with either of these pianos or has insights on their specs and overall performance, I would really appreciate your thoughts! Looking forward to your feedback.

Any advice would be immensely helpful!

Thanks!

4 Likes
2

I’ve tried both the Roland FP-10 and Yamaha P-45, and the Roland’s sound engine is definitely more advanced. The piano sounds are richer and more dynamic.

3

I agree! The polyphony on the FP-10 is also superior at 256 notes compared to only 64 on the P-45. This makes a big difference when playing complex pieces.

4

While the Roland excels in sound, don’t underestimate the P-45’s punchy tone. It can be surprisingly expressive for its price!

5

That’s true! Plus, the P-45 is lightweight and more portable. Perfect for gigging musicians.

6

Have you guys noticed any unique sound features in the FP-10? I love the Bluetooth MIDI option for connecting to apps.

7

Exactly! That feature is a game changer. The FP-10’s modern tech really enhances practice sessions.

8

In terms of audio output, the FP-10’s speakers are fuller. The sound really fills the room compared to the P-45’s more limited output.

9

The P-45’s sound is still pleasant, but I feel the FP-10 has more depth, especially with its sound engine that imitates acoustic pianos so well.

10

True! Plus, the Roland’s varied sound settings let you replicate different acoustic environments.

3 Likes
11

So, if the sound quality is your priority, I think the FP-10 is the clear winner. But does anyone have experiences using the P-45 for performance?

12

I’ve played gigs with the P-45 and loved its simplicity. It’s actually very reliable and does the job well for casual performances.

13

That’s a fair point! However, the FP-10 can take you to a whole new level with sound quality, especially for serious playing.

14

Can I just say the FP-10 is like the coffee of digital pianos? Strong and rich! Meanwhile, the P-45 is more like tea: nice and gentle. Am I alone on this?

7 Likes
15

Haha! That’s a great analogy! I guess it depends on our taste—some might prefer a subtler sound like the P-45.

16

Overall, it seems like if you’re serious about sound quality, the FP-10 is where to go. But the P-45 has its merits too, especially for beginners.

17

I’ve been looking into both pianos, and I must say, the Roland FP-10 is remarkably lightweight at about 25 lbs, making it great for portability. The Yamaha P-45 is heavier, around 26 lbs, but not by much. If I were traveling often, I’d lean towards the Roland.

18

Actually, the weight difference is hardly noticeable, but the portability of the FP-10 really stands out when I have to move it for gigs. Plus, the FP-10 has that solid build which feels great during setup.

19

I think it’s all about how you plan to use them. Are you mostly performing? If so, the lighter FP-10 could save you some hassle. But if it’s home use, the weight might not matter as much.

20

Good point! I do play at various venues, and the thought of lugging a heavier keyboard around is daunting. It’s nice to know the FP-10 is designed for easy transport.

5 Likes