I feel like there’s a nostalgic quality to piano rolls too. They connect us to the history of music production while still being relevant today.
That’s a good point! But do you think some genres benefit more from them than others?
I believe they are more beneficial in electronic genres, but classical pieces can also be structured effectively using them. What do you guys think?
4 Likes
Great discussion, but I wonder if we’re overvaluing piano rolls. They can simplify composition, but some argue they lead to formulaic writing. Thoughts?
That’s a valid concern, xwang. However, creativity still shines through the tool. It’s how we use it that counts.
I utilize them for some humorous projects too! If you need a cheesy or quirky sound, piano rolls can quickly create fun riffs.
3 Likes
That’s so true, jennamclean! Piano rolls can make even the silliest ideas easier to visualize and coordinate. They definitely have their playful side!
I’m curious about how professional composers perceive piano rolls. Are they seen as essential tools, or just another option?
It really depends on personal preference, bookerwilliam. Some swear by them, while others stick to traditional methods. The choice often reflects their unique workflow and style.
7 Likes
In the end, whether you use piano rolls or not, they certainly open up new possibilities for creativity. Reflecting on how everyone here uses them is inspiring!