Switching from Humbuckers to P-90s: What Should I Know?

Instruments Guitar and Bass
1

I’ve been playing guitar for a while now, mostly with humbucker pickups, and I’m looking into making the switch to P-90s. I’ve heard a lot about the unique tonal characteristics they offer, but I have some questions before I dive in.

Compatibility and Modifications

One of my main concerns is compatibility. Assuming my guitar is currently set up for humbuckers, what kind of modifications would I need to make the switch? Are there specific mounting considerations or wiring adjustments I should be aware of?

Sound Quality Differences

I’ve read that P-90s can deliver a bright, punchy sound with a bit of grit, which is quite different from the warmer tones of humbuckers. For those who’ve made this change, what was your experience regarding sound quality? Did you notice a significant difference in your playing style or in the genres of music you gravitate towards?

Practical Guidance

If anyone has made this switch, I’d love to hear about your experience. Were there any surprising challenges you faced? Also, do you have any tips for finding the right P-90s that complement the style you play?

Final Thoughts

I’m really looking to make this change as I want to expand my sound palette and explore new tones. Any advice, experiences, or recommendations would be greatly appreciated! Thanks in advance for your help!

2

Switching to P-90s can be quite a game-changer! They have a brighter, clearer tone compared to humbuckers, which tend to be warmer and more robust. If you play rock, blues, or jazz, P-90s really shine in those genres.

3

Great insights! I’ve heard some players describe P-90s as having more ‘growl’ than humbuckers. They can perfectly fit genres like surf rock and punk due to that gritty sound. Anyone else have experience with that?

4

Absolutely agree! P-90s have a unique punch, especially in vintage rock. Just remember they can be a bit noisy, so consider your setup!

7 Likes
5

Totally! I find that they cut through the mix so well, especially in a full band setting. But you do sacrifice some humbucker smoothness.

6

It really depends on your playing style too! I’ve used both, and while humbuckers are great for thick leads, P-90s are excellent for rhythm playing with that bite.

7

Couldn’t agree more! The clarity in P-90s can really elevate your rhythm playing, especially in funk or blues!

8 Likes
8

Switching from humbuckers to P-90s feels like a gamble. I love the character P-90s bring, but are they too bright for heavier styles like metal?

9

Well, it might be challenging since P-90s can sound thin with high gain. Maybe try a thicker gauge string or an EQ pedal to balance it out?

10

I’ve read that P-90s can handle crunch well. Imagine a grunge sound blending that gritty P-90 tone with distortion! Anyone play in that style?

11

Yes! P-90s definitely add a unique twist to grunge. Just be ready for some feedback action, but that can be fun!

12

Ultimately, switching pickups is personal! Maybe test a guitar with P-90s first before deciding, or consider a guitar with a split-coil option for more versatility. Thoughts?

3 Likes
13

Switching to P-90s can really change your tone! For installation, be prepared for potential routing since P-90s are wider than most humbuckers. You’ll want to check the depth of your cavities too.

14

That’s so true! I love the snappy sound of P-90s. Just make sure your guitar is ready for the change—electronic compatibility is key.

8 Likes
15

Absolutely! Plus, consider your amp settings. P-90s react differently than humbuckers, and you might need to tweak your tone controls to really get the best sound.

5 Likes
16

Routing can be a pain! Just take your time with it. I used a Dremel for my last swap. It makes the process a lot smoother if you’re comfortable with tools.

7 Likes
17

Dremel is a solid choice! Make sure you’ve got some practice wood handy, too. It’s easy to make mistakes if you’ve never routed before.

18

It’s also a good idea to double-check your wiring. P-90s might require a different approach than you’re used to with humbuckers. Don’t forget to solder properly!

19

For sure! Also, ensure your pots are compatible; you might want 500k pots for clarity.

20

Be prepared for some feedback too. P-90s are noisier than humbuckers, which can be a shock if you’re not used to it. But once you dial it in, the tone is fantastic!