Why I Can't Stand Mr. Big - Let's Discuss!

Off-Topic
1

Mr. Big has been a polarizing character for many fans of Sex and the City, and I personally fall into the camp that can hardly stand him. Here’s why:

The Charming Yet Frustrating Dynamic

  1. Emotional Manipulation: Mr. Big’s knack for frustrating Carrie is mind-boggling. It’s as if he enjoys having her chase after him, which feels super toxic. Does anyone else find his behaviors to be manipulative?
  2. Inconsistent Affection: One minute he’s all in, the next he’s ghosting. I can’t count how many times Carrie was left heartbroken because of him. Is that really love, or just a game he plays?
  3. Selfishness: It often feels like his needs come first, leaving Carrie in a constant state of uncertainty. That’s not a healthy relationship, and I wish the show spent more time highlighting that instead of romanticizing it.

The Debate

I know there are fans who defend Mr. Big, and I respect that. But for me, his character does more harm than good, perpetuating the idea that we should tolerate bad behavior in the name of love. What do you all think? Do you see him as a flawed romantic hero or just a problematic character? Let’s break it down together!

Share your thoughts below!

2

I can’t stand Mr. Big because he embodies a lot of toxic traits that many viewers overlook. His inconsistency and emotional unavailability really frustrate me.

3

I totally agree! It seems like he leads Carrie on just when he feels like it, which is really unfair for her.

4

Mr. Big’s character is intriguing, but his relationship dynamics with Carrie create so much unnecessary drama. It often feels like he’s just using her for his own gain.

5

Exactly! I think that lack of maturity makes viewers question his intentions.

5 Likes
6

Let’s not forget how he repeatedly broke Carrie’s heart. It’s one thing to be flawed, but he seems to enjoy the chase more than the commitment!

4 Likes
7

Oh, definitely! It’s almost like he’s addicted to the thrill of the hunt rather than actually loving Carrie.

8

But are we also being too harsh? Mr. Big may have his flaws, but he does show some moments of genuine love and care, right?

6 Likes
9

True, but those moments often feel overshadowed by his selfish actions. It’s hard to root for him.

1 Like
10

Isn’t it interesting how much our opinions can differ? Some people adore him for his charm and mystery, while others see the damage he causes.

11

For sure! It’s like he’s the bad boy everyone wants, but at what cost? I just can’t see him as a romantic hero.

12

Haha, Mr. Big’s name alone makes him sound like he’s got an oversized ego! He needs a reality check. Who does he think he is?

2 Likes
13

LOL! Right? He might as well get a trophy for worst boyfriend of the year at this point.

14

Mr. Big’s presence clearly complicates the emotional journeys of the female leads. He often represents the idealized but flawed notion of love that creates obstacles rather than opportunities for growth.

15

I completely agree! His character definitely serves as a catalyst for the other characters to explore their own insecurities, even if it feels frustrating at times.

16

I think Mr. Big is more of a hindrance. The repeated back and forth between him and Carrie makes it feel like she never fully grows into her best self. It’s exhausting to watch.

17

That’s an interesting take! I feel like that struggle she faces is precisely what pushes her towards her own self-discovery later on.

18

I find Mr. Big a bit comical, honestly. His indecisiveness is almost cartoonish! But I can see how it might highlight the strength of other female characters.

19

Exactly! It adds an element of humor, but I do wonder if that undermines the serious themes of relationships and personal growth in the show.

3 Likes
20

Honestly, I think Mr. Big’s character is a reflection of real-life relationships. They are often messy and complicated, which can either hinder us or help us evolve.

4 Likes